California considers strict ‘George Floyd’ law to punish police who fail to intervene

Outraged that Minneapolis officers stood by while their colleague killed George Floyd, California lawmakers are considering a tough law to punish police who fail to intervene when witnessing potential excessive force — including possible criminal charges and being banned from law enforcement.

If enacted, the proposed law would put California at the forefront of legal efforts to criminalize the “blue code of silence” that many say contributed to Floyd’s death.

But the bill, authored by Assemblyman Chris Holden (D-Pasadena), has set off a fight with law enforcement agencies around the state who contend the rule is largely redundant but places a criminal penalty on officers during situations that often involve split-second decisions.

Floyd, a Black man, was killed on May 25 by Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, who placed his knee on Floyd’s neck for almost eight minutes, until Floyd became unresponsive. Three other officers at the scene failed to stop Chauvin, though Floyd said he could not breathe.

“It shattered my heart,” said Holden. “It was the inaction of the other officers that caused a real concern because they never tried to stop it.”

Chauvin has been charged with third-degree murder, second-degree murder and manslaughter. His three colleagues, Thomas Lane, Tou Thao and J. Alexander Kueng, have been charged with aiding and abetting second-degree murder and manslaughter.

Holden’s bill would make bystander officers an accessory to any crime committed by the officer using undue force if they failed to take action.

Holden said that despite current mandates and policies that give officers a duty to intervene, his measure is needed to clarify what that action means and how officers should be trained. It would also provide whistleblower protections to officers who report excessive force, and prohibit a person from remaining an officer if they were found to have used excessive force unnecessarily that resulted to great bodily injury or death, or failed to intervene in that situation.

“There needs to be physical intervention,” he said. “There also needs to be making sure that the body camera is on, that there is an effort to deescalate the situation.”

But law enforcement officials said the bill is unfair to officers because it doesn’t take into account that the Floyd case, in which officers had time to react, is an anomaly. They said that most use-of-force happens quickly, and often in chaotic situations, and that holding officers to an inflexible duty to intervene is not practical or fair.

“This misguided proposal criminalizes officers who may not have a complete understanding of the incident and have different viewpoints. Strong policies, robust training and fair discipline is far more appropriate than criminal sanctions,” said the board of directors of the Los Angeles Police Protective League in a statement.

Ed Obayashi, a statewide police trainer, said that measure was “impractical” and presented a broad solution to a narrow problem. Obayashi said that a situation like Floyd’s death, where other officers are present but not actively taking part, is rare, and legislating for it could create confusion in more common situations.

He gave the example of recent protests where the use of rubber bullets and other projectiles have been questioned as excessive force, pointing out that it would have been difficult for other officers present in those situations to determine if the force was warranted and if they had a duty to intervene.

“It’s a slippery slope because what are you going to say, that you’ve got 30 officers in a skirmish line and one deploys a projectile and it hits someone in the head. What are the other officers supposed to do?” he asked.

The proposal also drew the ire of law enforcement for language that would have upended a deal brokered last year to pass Assembly Bill 392, which revamped California’s use of force law. That contentious measure brought weeks of emotional protests to the Capitol in the wake of the shooting of Stephon Clark by Sacramento police who mistook his cellphone for a gun.

Gov. Gavin Newsom engineered a last-minute compromise between law enforcement and reform advocates that convinced police to end the opposition to the measure, but softened some of its language. That deal largely centered on the definition, or lack of it, of a single word: necessary.

Politics

Why California’s proposed law on deadly police force isn’t as tough as it seems

Politics

Why California’s proposed law on deadly police force isn’t as tough as it seems

In the aftermath of several controversial police shootings in California, activists and victims’ families have hoped their anguish would lead to action.

Police reform advocates wanted a clear definition that deadly force could only be used when other options had been exhausted. Law enforcement argued successfully that the strict definition was not always possible. The word was ultimately left in the law, but its meaning left to the discretion of prosecutors and courts.

Earlier this week, a definition of what “necessary” means was added to both Holden’s bill and another by the author of AB 392, Shirley Weber (D-San Diego).

Law enforcement lobbyists were angered, considering it a backdoor measure to undo the deal brokered by Newsom.

Holden said Wednesday he was unaware of the significance of the language, and is in the process of removing that portion of the bill. He said it was “recently brought to our attention that this was part of the governor’s negotiation with law enforcement with [AB] 392″ and it was not his intent to change the state’s use of force law again.

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.

Anita Chabria covers California state politics and policy for the Los Angeles Times and is based in Sacramento. Before joining The Times, she worked for the Sacramento Bee as a member of its statewide investigative team, and previously covered criminal justice and City Hall.

California

California could create its own $600 weekly unemployment benefit

California

California could create its own $600 weekly unemployment benefit

Assemblyman Phil Ting said there is support for providing up to $600 weekly to jobless Californians

Dodgers

Plaschke: Joe Kelly finds his place in Dodgers lore by banging hard on trash-can Astros

Dodgers

Plaschke: Joe Kelly finds his place in Dodgers lore by banging hard on trash-can Astros

Joe Kelly released the months of pent-up rage the Dodgers and their fans have been feeling ever since MLB found the Houston Astros cheated in 2017.

California

L.A. County shuts down three food businesses over unreported COVID-19 outbreaks

California

L.A. County shuts down three food businesses over unreported COVID-19 outbreaks

Television

‘Watchmen’ leads 2020 Emmy nominations; ‘Mrs. Maisel,’ ‘Ozark’ also score big

Television

‘Watchmen’ leads 2020 Emmy nominations; ‘Mrs. Maisel,’ ‘Ozark’ also score big

The 2020 Emmy nominations are being announced Tuesday morning by host Leslie Jones, alongside presenters Laverne Cox, Josh Gad and Tatiana Maslany.

California

Less stress, better grades: With schools closed, some kids thrive

California

Less stress, better grades: With schools closed, some kids thrive

When the pandemic caused schools to shutter, some students relished more free time, less-stressful classes and a lack of bullying.

World & Nation

‘We’ve let our guard down’: Europe battles to contain new coronavirus surge

World & Nation

‘We’ve let our guard down’: Europe battles to contain new coronavirus surge

After weathering what they thought was the worst of the COVID-19 crisis, European countries are seeing new spikes in infections as restrictions ease.

California

Health crisis looming inside a health crisis: People are avoiding going to the doctor

California

Health crisis looming inside a health crisis: People are avoiding going to the doctor

Americans are avoiding hospitals and clinics, even when they shouldn’t be. Experts expect a jump in preventable diseases after the pandemic eases.

Lifestyle

Full bladders, closed bathrooms. Strategies for peeing while out during coronavirus

Lifestyle

Full bladders, closed bathrooms. Strategies for peeing while out during coronavirus

Travelers are finding many public restrooms closed these days, due to the pandemic. Here’s what you need to know about finding a place to go when you’re on the go.

Lifestyle

Your friend is throwing a party during a pandemic. How do you say no?

Lifestyle

Your friend is throwing a party during a pandemic. How do you say no?

How to politely turn down an invitation to socialize while there’s still a pandemic going on.

California

COVID-19 outbreak confirmed at San Diego gym operating illegally

California

COVID-19 outbreak confirmed at San Diego gym operating illegally

San Diego County announces plans to step up compliance efforts after the outbreak at the Pacific Beach gym.

California

Divers pull Paralympic hopeful’s prosthetic leg from ocean floor off Long Beach

California

Divers pull Paralympic hopeful’s prosthetic leg from ocean floor off Long Beach

Rescue divers have pulled Paralympic hopeful DeWalt Mix’s prosthetic leg from the bottom of a Long Beach marina after several days of searching.

California

4-year-old boy dies and his little brother is injured in Pasadena apartment fire

California

4-year-old boy dies and his little brother is injured in Pasadena apartment fire

A child dies in an apartment fire in Pasadena. The child’s sibling and mother are seriously injured.

California

Union representing father of Andres Guardado calls on sheriff to resign

California

Union representing father of Andres Guardado calls on sheriff to resign

Several advocate groups are calling on Sheriff Alex Villanueva to step down in wake of fatal deputy shooting of Andres Guardado.

California

Newsom announces ‘strike team’ for California’s unemployment agency as 1 million await benefits

California

Newsom announces ‘strike team’ for California’s unemployment agency as 1 million await benefits

Many people who lost jobs or income in California due to coronavirus say they have been unable to get the benefits for which they are eligible.

Sign up for the latest news, best stories and what they mean for you, plus answers to your questions.

You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.

Source: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-07-29/california-considers-strict-law-for-officers-who-fail-in-duty-to-intervene

George Floyd

World news – NG – California considers strict ‘George Floyd’ law to punish police who fail to intervene

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *